I use this pencil a lot. It goes on creamy, and is nicely pigmented. It is a pain to sharpen, so you'll need to get it cold to sharpen it. It doesn't last all day, but it lasts for many hours before fading(even on my waterline). It can smudge, but I onę noticed product on my hand and not my face. I would buy these again if they were on sale.

This is not as dark as I would expect a dark brown to be. It sort of between dark and medium. It's also slightly bronze. That surprised me, since the color name didn't hint that there would be any shimmer. The pencil is a bit of a pain to sharpen, because the liner is creamy. Which is really nice for applying, but it gets stuck in my sharpener. I have to get the pencil cold to sharpen it. Other than that I have no complaints. It doesn't last all day, but it does last for many hours before fading begins. It's not smudge proof, so be careful. I have accidentally smudged it, though it wasn't noticeable on my face. I happend to notice some liner on my hand was all. I would buy these again if they were on sale.

I love this eyeliner. I own it in black and I use it everyday.

The applicator is a brush type, which takes a little time to get used to. However, I perfer it to felt tip.

This eyeliner does not wear off. I wear it from 6am-9pm every day. This includes a 1.5 hour swim practice and it still stays on!

The product in the bottle does tend to dry up after a little while (a year or so) but I throw mine out then anyway because I don't want to have bateria.

Overall, this is a wonderful product at a cheap price.

Great two in one eyeliner combo, Very inexpensive, doesn't smudge and is pretty smooth. Be sure to keep it out of waterline, it's really not meant for that area, it will run and smudge like crazy in your eye.

I was not satisfied at all with this product. If your looking for products that work on the inner rims this is not for you.. The packaging is incredibly cheap and the botom half will also come off when you take of the cap. It was only two dollars, so if you line the outside of your eye and don't mind the bad packaging go ahead.

I love how you get two eyeliner colors in one, so you don't have to go searching around for two basic colored eyeliners all over the place. The black is pure black, not a gray-ish color that I usually get, and the brown that comes with it is awesome! It might be my favorite shade of brown in an eyeliner I have.

I've been using these for years now, and will continue to, since it lines my eyes and stays pretty nicely on me. One of the best cheap and cheerful buys!

I wrote a rave for this liner here, and knew I should write a review.  You can get a lot more details on my thoughts from the thread, but I'll give you the gist of it here.

 

These liners are awesome!  No running or fading from the waterline, goes on smooth as silk, and cost 1/4 of MUFE's Aqua Eyes Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils.  13 hours later, as I sit and write this review, I still have an awesome black line on my waterline just as if I just applied it!

 

Most girls can probably find these anywhere NYC is found, which makes it great for those who don't have a lot of major brands around them.

 

I highly recommend these for anyone looking for a great, waterproof liner.  Be it for your waterline or lashlines.  I definitely plan on repurchasing these liners, and will probably stock up on all of the colors available (Black, Dark Brown, Mink, Smoky Plum, Moody Blue, Sky High and Teal).